★★★★★ 5.0 · 142 Google reviews · Licensed agent since 1999 800-320-6269
Free help from a real licensed California agent. No pressure. No cost. Same rate as going direct.
Book a time to talk
California health insurance - Individual health insurance - Downside of Group health benefits

When is Group Health Insurance a Burden To The Employee

Covered California Subsidies Explained in 2026 (Watch Before You Enroll!) - Watch on YouTube

The law of unintended consequences seems to be in full effect these days when it comes to California health insurance and it's very prominent in our recent analysis of how group health options will affect employee's insurance costs. We'll try to keep this from spiraling into a complicated explanation but it won't be easy! So, why might an employee not want you to offer group health insurance?

At Play...Health Subsidies

Let's first touch base on the health subsidies available to Californians on the individual family market.

If an individual or family makes under 400% of the Federal Poverty Level (links below for these amounts), they may qualify for large health subsidies towards the purchase of insurance on the Exchange.

We are talking about $1000's of dollars in subsidies per year. There are a few caveats in order to qualify and this is where the group health insurance coverage comes into play.

In most cases, if a person is OFFERED (not necessarily accepting) group health coverage which is deemed both affordable AND meeting the Minimum Value requirements, that employee is not eligible to get subsidies for themselves OR their dependents on the Individual Family Health Exchange.

The dependent's inability to qualify for subsidies is the critical piece that wasn't probably intended with the original law. HHS later came out and clarified that this exclusion would hold. Let's first look at the two requirements for the Group health plans.

What is affordable and minimum value?

Affordable means that an employee cannot be expected to pay more than 9.5% of their income towards their share of the EMPLOYEE only premium.

The Minimum Value designation means that the plan meets at least the 60% actuarial value (essentially the Bronze plan level) requirement.

If the Group health plan meets these two requirements for a given employee, that employee is unable to go to the individual Health exchange and qualify for subsidies.

His or her dependents are also unable to qualify for subsidies unless the group plan does not offer coverage (different from does not pay for) dependent coverage which is extremely rare.

The employee's dependents are left without options

So where does this leave the employee's dependents if eligible group coverage is offered to the Employee? It is an unanticipated loop hole which presents the dependents few good options. Some groups do not pay for dependent coverage or pay less than they would for employee coverage. Even if the family makes less than the 400% of the federal poverty level, the fact that they are offered group coverage makes them in-eligible.

We'll watch to see if this loop hole is addressed as it will affect 1000's of Californians adversely and does not seem to fit the intent of the original Health Reform bill.

Our guess is that the original bill writers did not want groups to encourage their lower wage (under 400% poverty level) to just opt out of the group plan and get subsidies on the individual market.

It may have a similar effect in that the companies just stop offering group health insurance so that employees can take advantage of subsidies. Time will tell but we're happy to walk through how to best navigate this as either an employee, dependent, or California company.

You can run your Covered California Plan Quote here to view rates and plans side by side from the major carriers...Free.

Again, there is absolutely no cost to you for our services. Call 800-320-6269 Today!

Frequently Asked Questions
▸ What is the downside of being offered group health insurance in California?
If your employer offers group health insurance that meets federal 'affordable' and 'minimum value' standards, you and your household members who are covered under that offer are generally blocked from receiving subsidies on Covered California - even if the plan doesn't suit your needs. This is one of the most common surprises California employees face when exploring individual coverage options.
▸ Can I turn down my employer's group health insurance and get Covered California instead?
You can decline your employer's offer, but if that offer is considered 'affordable' and meets minimum value requirements under current rules, you would typically be ineligible for premium subsidies through Covered California. It's worth speaking with a licensed agent before making that decision, since the financial impact varies by situation.
▸ What makes an employer health plan 'affordable' under California rules?
Affordability is generally based on the employee's share of the premium for employee-only coverage relative to their household income - the dependents' costs are not factored into this test. This means a plan can be deemed 'affordable' even if adding family members would cost significantly more. Learn more about California employer coverage requirements.
▸ What happens to an employee's dependents if the employer plan is too expensive for the family?
If the employer's offer is deemed 'affordable' for the employee alone, dependents who can't afford to join the group plan may be left without subsidy access on Covered California - sometimes called the 'family glitch.' Federal rules have attempted to address this, but the specifics change, so consulting a licensed agent is strongly recommended.
▸ Can a licensed agent help me compare group coverage versus individual Covered California plans?
Yes - a licensed California agent can help you weigh the true cost and coverage differences between an employer's group offer and individual market options at no cost to you; you pay the same premium as going direct. Get a free individual/family quote or call CalHealth.net to speak with an agent serving all of California.
The answers above are general information about California health insurance and may change as rates, plans, and rules are updated each year. They are not a substitute for personalized advice. For current, personalized guidance, please contact us, email help@calhealth.net, or call 800-320-6269. Serving California since 1994.
Free Covered California Quote
Google ★★★★★ 5.0
⚡ Free & Instant

Compare Covered California plans with your subsidy from Kaiser, Blue Shield, Anthem & more - side by side, right now. No forms, no waiting for a callback.

See My Plans & PricesNeed a real person? →
Serving California since 1994 · 600,000+ quotes · Zero cost for our help