These two carriers actually share a history!
Anthem Blue Cross is definitely the bigger carrier but Health net has certain niche areas where it does really well.
To some extent, Health net is trying to copy Blue Cross' original path to market dominance.
They're doing this just as Anthem is going a different direction...towards a nationwide carrier.
With the good and bad that entails!
So let's compare the two carriers based on 1000's of clients and 100's of 1000's interactions over 25+ years.
The last few 5-7 years have seen big changes with both carriers.
Since each market segment is different, you can jump to the section that pertains to you here:
First...a quick history lesson and then we'll look at how each carrier operates generally.
This is important because it speaks to the carriers' strengths and weaknesses.
Here's a top level comparison across all markets!
We'll start with Health Net.
A few decades back, Anthem Blue Cross wanted to become a public company as opposed to a non-profit.
At that time, the parent company was Wellpoint.
California was their primary market.
The State Department of Insurance required them to split off their HMO business in order to make this change.
The carved out HMO business became (drum roll please)....
A publicly traded company that was all HMO.
That was 1979!!
Health Net flourished as an aggressive HMO provider until the the very model itself ran into trouble.
As of today, Health Net offers PPO, EPO, and HMO plans in all three major segments although the individual/family market has seen more of an HMO focus since 2014 (Covered California).
In an increasingly fragmented and competitive market, Health Net continues to function which is not easy considering their size.
Again...niche markets is where they excel now.
We'll talk about that in the individual sections.
What about Anthem Blue Cross?
As we mentioned above, Anthem had to split off their HMO business to go public.
Leonard Schaeffer basically transformed them into a dominant powerhouse.
There was a time that Blue Cross of California was just miserable to deal with.
So incredibly difficult.
Leonard Schaeffer righted the ship.
Anthem then became the dominant carrier in California and even went into other States.
They really drove innovation in the California health market.
First online application.
On and on and on.
Which we're not big fans of.
They are not as easy to deal with as they used to be.
It's more a longing for the old days when they were awesome!
The focus is more on being a nationwide carrier which is good in terms of withstanding all the changes but California is not Indiana.
It's really competitive and California members have certain expectations.
There's definitely a difference now with the power moving to Indiana.
Keep in mind...Anthem is a dominant carrier in California.
Generally one of the top 3 in terms of membership.
Their presence has slipped a bit but they're still strong.
Anthem offers a full range of HMO, PPO, and EPO plans with all ancilliary add-ons such as dental, vision, life, etc.
But health insurance really revolves around the specific market.
Let's get into that.
You can jump to your section here:
We'll start with individual and family
We'll break our comparison into these categories:
A few quick notes on Anthem and Health Net in the individual market.
The big question first.
Do they participate in Covered California?
Both carriers currently offer coverage both on and off exchange.
Health Net focuses more on the HMO model of options on-exchange.
Anthem focuses more on the EPO/PPO model of plans.
We'll discuss this in the network section.
So the net net is this...
Let's get started with the sections!
This really depends on which type of plan you're looking for.
Typically, you'll see Health Net's rates just above the regional HMO's like Molina and LA Care.
Their PPO/EPO plans (when available) have not been very competitive on average.
Blue Shield PPO or Blue Cross EPO generally are priced better.
As for Anthem Blue Cross' pricing, the HMO generally only makes sense if your provider only take Anthem HMO.
The pricing has been better with other HMO's.
In a given area, it has usually been a comparison between Anthem's EPO and Blue Shield's PPO if you need more flexibility or your doctors only take EPO/PPO.
Sometimes Anthem is cheaper. Other times, they're not.
You really need to run a personalized quote here to see how your area is priced:
You can also use our PlanFinder tool to compare the plan levels and options.
It's a great resource!
Right now, we're not terribly impressed by either for customer service.
Anthem Blue Cross has become more of a nationwide carrier and that results in a little less access to California clients.
It's just a function of becoming really big and centralized.
Health Net has traditionally focused on pricing aggressively and less on systems to manage membership.
We can't get excited about either.
Our thought is this...if pricing and the network are good, that's the deciding factor.
It outweighs having to engage a phone bank now then when there's a mess up on the membership side.
We mentioned this above but here's a big difference between the two.
First, there's the focus of network type between the two carriers.
That's been their bread and butter since 2014 and even before then.
In some areas, they are priced much lower than Anthem's HMO.
Always check with your doctors and ask "what Covered Ca plans do you take" first.
Say Covered Ca since the offices all know this branding and there are different networks out there now.
I've seen medical groups that take Health Net's HMO network but not PPO/EPO networks with other carriers which is very odd.
Check there first.
The networks are much smaller now.
This is true across the carriers since 2014 for individual/family plans.
Health Net's HMO network is much smaller.
It's typically bigger than competing regional HMO networks such as LA Care or Molina but smaller than Anthem's HMO network and much smaller than the EPO/PPO networks available.
As you can guess...doctor networks are a real issue now.
If there are doctors you must have, it's important to start there and then look as plan levels and rates!
To the member, their online services are pretty comparable.
Both are adequate and functional.
Neither of them shine but that's pretty typical for health insurance carriers.
Anthem might have the slight edge on ease of use but nothing's too easy carrier online systems.
These services are expected with either carrier:
Anthem used to have a much broader drug formulary than Health Net but that's changed!
Some real basic drugs are missing off it.
Health Net's drug list isn't terribly robust either.
A big reason for this is that the carriers are scrambling to make the individual/family market work since 2014.
They are trying to cut anywhere they can.
This trend will probably not change unfortunately.
We can email over the current formulary for both carriers upon request.
First, see if Health Net and/or Anthem Blue Cross are even available in your area through our quote tool below.
They may not be!
Secondly, decide on the network type you prefer...HMO or PPO/EPO
Finally, consider the pricing difference between different levels for the two carriers.
I.e. Silver EPO with Anthem versus Silver HMO with Health Net.
Usually, people have a strong preference regarding HMO versus PPO.
You can compare the two carrier's plans and rates here:
Of course, we're happy to help with any questions as Certified Covered California agents.
Our assistance is 100% free to you.
Now, let's look at Small Business plans.
Now, we're going to see some competition.
Both carriers are very aggressive in the small employer market and it shows.
We run 1000's of group health quotes for companies.
The same trends keep coming up.
Keep in mind that the benefits are standardized.
This means a Silver plan has to walk and talk like another Silver plan +/- 2%.
That then leaves pricing and network.
Focus on those two items when comparing the carriers.
Let's get started with the big one these days.
Let's face it...
This is what every employer cares about these days.
Employers are scrambling.
So how do Anthem Blue Cross and Health Net compare?
Let's look by network type.
Again, we run 1000's of proposals for companies.
Your area and demographic may be different but...
You can request your Group health quote here to find out.
What about HMO?
For HMO, Health Net definitely comes to the table in terms of pricing.
Keep in mind that they won't beat Kaiser but for employees that want their own doctors and like the cost savings of HMO, this is Health Net's bread and butter.
When you run your quote, make sure to request which type of network and carrier.
We can quote them side by side for you.
There are so many plans and networks (new narrow PPO and HMO networks) to quote so any guidance you have on priorities will help.
Run your Group quote here:
Both carriers do a better job for Employer plans than they do for individual/family.
Keep in mind that Anthem Blue Cross led the charge in responsiveness and ease of use up until about 5-7 years ago when Indiana started wielding more control.
Health Net has been able to stay more nimble and responsive as a smaller, regional carrier.
We deal with the carriers daily for membership issues.
Health Net is slightly easier to get things done with.
Edge goes to Health Net.
Ultimately, the feel to the employee will be pretty comparable so pricing and network still dominate the decision before customer service.
If we're your licensed agent, we can take all the headaches out of membership issues anyway.
No cost for our services!
Let's look at the second biggest consideration (after pricing)...Networks.
The employer market has largely avoided the incredible paring down of doctor networks that individual/family and Covered Ca have seen.
In fact, on the employer side, the networks haven't changed much through the ACA transition even though the plan benefits and pricing have.
You still want to check on employee's doctors but it's not uncommon to find most medical providers accept both Anthem and Health Net PPOs.
If a provider accepts HMO's, it's pretty common to see both.
Make sure to double check.
When we run your quote, we can send over links to the provider networks for either carrier.
You will always have certain doctors that only take one or the other (or neither) so checking first is a great start.
The group side online services are definitely getting there but not quite where Blue Shield of California is.
There is both an Employer portal and employee portal.
The Employer portal allows for basic membership detail and changes for either carrier.
The Employee portal allows for claims detail, membership access, and doctor lists primarily (billing not included since employer pays).
The online services are steadily improving but pretty comparable between two carriers now.
So here's the deal.
Anthem was the first carrier to pare back the group RX formulary list for all plans.
Every carrier did that for the individual family plans but employer plans??
That was a bold move.
Here's the trade-off.
Health net has a more traditional (stronger) RX list for employees but the pricing has been higher.
There's a direct correlation which makes sense since drug prices have driven the fast escalation of health plan coverage costs over the past 2 decades!
In many cases, Anthem is going to win this battle.
Pricing is just too big of a consideration.
This may be the best approach so that we have Anthem's PPO and Kaiser's HMO (pricing is hard to beat).
We can quote this option and show you how to make it works seamlessly.
Request quote here for all options:
When we're comparing Medicare options, we basically have to look at Advantage Plans versus Medicare Supplements
How are Health Net and Anthem for either one.
Let's break it up since they're so different.
Both Health Net and Anthem offer Advantage plans in certain areas of California.
You can quote the Advantage plans side by side here:
Both have strong offerings in this space.
Health Net traditionally is a strong HMO carrier.
Anthem saw a huge market and went after it aggressively.
We'll discuss in the Price and Network sections how to compare the two.
Anthem has always been a dominant Supplement carrier.
In fact, they were leaders in the market for this type of plan.
Health net came onto the scene later but they are really aggressive with pricing...especially for the current F plan (soon to be phased out but very popular).
The networks are the same as well.
It's pricing and pricing stability.
We'll discuss this as well.
We'll compare Health Net and Anthem Blue Cross for these categories:
Back to our two categories...Advantage plans and Supplements.
Advantage Plan pricing for Health Net and Blue Cross
Okay...this is a little more involved.
The benefits can vary with Advantage plans.
In general, they are low or no cost on a monthly basis.
That's the monthly premium only.
What about when you get sick or hurt?
That's where things can be different.
You can run your Medicare Advantage quote here to compare.
Especially the max out of pocket.
It's very easy to hit that number these days when you're over age 65.
There isn't a clear winner in terms of pricing.
It differs by area and by person's age.
You have to run the quote..
We have dedicated agents who help you evaluate the options at no cost to you.
You still need to run your quote for your particular situation but in general...
Health Net has been very aggressive with the F plan.
Anthem Blue Cross has been very aggressive with it's replacement, the G plan.
There's then a question of the F plan or G plan.
We're happy to walk through why directly based on your rates.
Run your Supplement quote here:
Both carriers are equally backwards here but it's not entirely their fault.
There are layers and layers of red tape and protection for Seniors.
The carriers are only allowed to do so much and it shows.
In general, Medicare itself dictates whether a claims are paid and the carrier is tied into their system so that side is streamlined.
That's pretty comparable between the two with Anthem having slightly better results.
In general...they are pretty comparable and most Medicare plans are pretty streamlined.
The network for Supplements are very easy.
The supplement pays accordingly.
This is the second biggest consideration behind pricing for Advantage plans.
Since the plans are HMO by definition, there is a distinct network that you must stay within (other than a true emergency).
If there are doctors or hospitals you want to stay with, make sure to ask them what Advantage plans they take or check online directories through the quote here:
It's really important to look at the network.
In general, Anthem has had the stronger Advantage plan networks but it's important to double check your providers.
Don't expect too much here.
In time, this may change but it will be very slow.
The carriers are pretty similar here for now.
RX is carved out for Supplements.
You can quote/compare the options right through www.medicare.gov
Again, there are certain carriers that really run away with that market in terms of pricing and options.
For the Advantage plan, RX may be included in the core benefits.
It's important to look at the list of allowed medications.
Again...with Advantage plans, we have lower monthly premium but more exposure when sick or hurt (or at the pharmacy!)
You can quote the Senior plans here.
Okay...two big carriers on the market with an intertwined history.
Depending on your market (individual/family, small business, senior), they can be a top performer in the market.
The market is so fragmented now that you really have to quote them for each given situation.
We're happy to help you compare the two carriers against others on the market.
How can we help?
Again, there is absolutely no cost to you for our services. Call 800-320-6269 Today!